When a bestselling author isn’t really a bestselling author

Or not!

Or not!

Do you have a book you want to appear in the top ten of a “prestigious” bestsellers list?  Yes?  Okay, next question.  Do you have $85,000 to pay a company called ResultSource to manipulate your book sales for a day?  The sudden spike in sales will flash on the radar of bestselling lists and wham, bam, call it a scam, your book is listed as a bestseller.  Now, your sales will drop precipitously after you’ve reached such dramatic literary heights, but that doesn’t matter.  You can forever call yourself a bestselling author.

According to an article in the Wall Street Journal, here’s how it works.  ResultSource will use a portion of the $85K you paid, and “arrange the purchase of a quantity of books in such a way that they (are) counted toward national best-seller lists.”

In other words, enough books (2500-3000) will be purchased by a stable of buyers on a certain day to give you a sales spike.  ResultSource will reimburse those buyers for their purchase, and, I imagine, kick in a little “commission” for their efforts.  Now, part of this is conjecture on my part because ResultSource has never really revealed how their formula works, but common sense sheds a little light on the darker aspects of this fraud.

The article only addresses this tactic being used for business books, but I’m willing to bet that other categories and genres are afflicted by this dishonest practice.  Authors do not reap riches for their investment.  They merely use it to acquire the title of “Bestselling Author” to apply to their website, business cards, and Christmas newsletter for family and friends.  They may get a speaking engagement or two out of the deal, and a front of the line pass at Starbucks, but other than that this truly has a horrific ROI (Return On Investment).  You would think business book authors would know better.

The truly astonishing thing that one learns from this article is how few books you actually have to sell to appear in the top ten bestsellers lists from The New York Times to The Business Journal.

Authors who have used ResultSource have discovered that there is no lasting effect from their enormous investment.  You think?  They create artificial demand for a brief period of time.  The key to a books popularity and sales isn’t the people who buy it.  It’s the people who read it.  ResultSource isn’t finding readers for authors.  They’re finding buyers who will never crack it open.  They’ll never fall in love with it or find anything of value in it.  They’ll never rush to Facebook or Twitter to tell their friends and followers about it.  They’ll never call up their BFF or mom and insist they read this great new book they discovered.

You can manipulate a bestseller list for a brief moment in time, but you can’t manipulate readers.

Arm outstretched. Microphone dropped.

2 thoughts on “When a bestselling author isn’t really a bestselling author

  1. This is how books “written” by the likes of Sarah Palin are”bestsellers” in one instance, and then cluttering up the Bargain Bin in the next.

    • Absolutely correct, Deacon. The “Bestseller” system is deeply flawed and needs to be revamped. Some smart person can come up with a fancy algorithm that is more accurate, I’m sure.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s