How to decide which side to take in the Amazon/Hachette dispute


The Amazon/Hachette brouhaha has been so difficult to figure out. It’s hard to know which side to support. Let’s face it, we’re talking about two corporations worth billions fighting over mo’ money. It’s a tad bit difficult to relate. Some authors with major lit-cred have been working hard to sway public opinion in Hachette’s favor because they feel like Amazon has stabbed them in the back. Meanwhile, Amazon has accused Hachette of using its authors as “human shields.” In short, it’s getting nasty. As an indie author, I really don’t have a stake in this fight, but as a reader, I do.

Today it hit me that there’s a very easy way to decide which side you’re on in this thing. I’ll break up this handy-dandy guide in two sections – one for readers and the other one for authors.

The Reader Amazon/Hachette guide:

A. I want to pay higher prices for e-books from traditional publishing companies like Hachette.
B. I want to pay lower prices for e-books from traditional publishing companies like Hachette.

If you selected ‘A’, you support Hachette. If you selected ‘B’, you support Amazon.

 

The Author Amazon/Hachette guide:

A. I want to help foster and force change in the publishing industry that will ultimately give authors a more equitable share of royalties earned on their books.
B. I want to keep things the same and maintain the current royalty structures that see authors earn a minuscule amount of royalties earned on their books.

If you selected ‘A’, you support Amazon. If you selected ‘B’, you support Hachette.

In the words of Nick Burns Your company’s computer guy, “Oh by the way, you’re welcome!”

A note:  Believe it or not, I’m not one of those indie authors that doesn’t see a future for traditional publishing companies.  I do, but not under the current business model.  They have to adapt to accommodate the changes in technology and retail. The music industry fought to hold on to the old way of doing business until there was virtually no music industry left to hold on to.  The publishing industry needs to get in front of this thing before it’s too late.  The first order of business is to get rid of the current industry standard contracts and form partnership deals with their authors, ones that give authors, at the very least, half of the royalties earned on print sales and more than half on e-book sales.  The second order of business is to ditch six-figure and up advances and scale up marketing dollars.  The third order of business is to hire back all the editors you’ve let go over the years.  They are the major factor in taking an average book and making it great.

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “How to decide which side to take in the Amazon/Hachette dispute

  1. You’ve confirmed what I have been thinking. Every time I read something on the dispute I leaned more towards the Amazon side than Hachette. I honestly cannot see paying higher prices for ebooks. Ebooks means no printing company, shipping or storage fees for the publisher. So why should I pay more for an ebook than I do for the paperback? For that same reason I am skittish about paying the same amount of the paperback as for the ebook.

    • And you’ve confirmed what Amazon said in a statement released yesterday. I posted about it on the blog. They demonstrated that not only do consumers stay away from higher priced ebooks, but lower priced ebooks ($9.99) sell more copies and make a higher profit for the publisher. They backed their claims with research so it’s hard to refute, but I imagine Douglas Preston and Hachette will.

      • I just read that blog. Again, Amazon is proving that they are in business FOR consumers and authors as they should be. They understand commerce for all. It seems that Hachette only understands putting more money in their own pockets. That is not commerce. That is greed.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s